Although first
published sixty years ago, this is still a valuable book for those interested
in the crusades and the crusader states. It is logically organized looking
first at the strategic framework, the composition of the armies of both
Christians and Muslims, then finally at the tactics employed. By avoiding a chronological narrative, Smail highlights
how certain features of warfare remained the same — or changed — over time.
The
book provides adequate footnotes for scholars, but the text itself does not
often become bogged down in arguments with fellow scholars about details of
little interest to the general reader. The book also provides some useful
sketches and photos of some of the crusader castles. While the reader may not
agree with all of Smail’s theses (more recent research casts doubt on his
assumptions about the hostility of the native population, for example), his
arguments are cogent and stimulate further thought an analysis.
You're loading me down with reading, Professor! LOL
ReplyDelete